Caleb Ingersoll

Lead Pastor

[email protected]


Pastor Caleb Ingersoll is from Northwood, IA and completed his undergraduate studies in Biology at Northwestern College in Orange City, IA. He met his wife Diane, who is from Holland, NE, at college and they were married in July 2004. In August 2005, they moved to South Hamilton, MA where Caleb attended Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary.

Caleb and Diane began regularly attending Calvary Baptist Church in December 2005 and invested in the people and mission of the church. In September 2007, Caleb was asked to be the interim pastor as the previous pastor had moved. Caleb and Diane dedicated themselves to the church and in September 2009, Caleb accepted the official role as pastor of Calvary. Their daughter, Jillian Joy, was born June 2011; their son, Benjamin Zumer, was born October 2013; and they have a feisty orange cat named Kisa. They are passionate for serving God in this ministry and would love to help you get involved as well!

Andy Katzmire

Associate Pastor

[email protected]


Pastor Andy Katzmire is from Harrisburg, PA and completed his undergraduate degree in Elementary Education from Indiana University of Pennsylvania (IUP) in Indiana, PA. After graduating from college he worked for four years on staff with Campus Crusade for Christ at IUP. During that time he met his wife Christy, who is from Maryland and was also serving on staff with Campus Crusade. They were married in October 2005. In August 2006 they moved to South Hamilton, MA where they attended Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary.

Andy and Christy began regularly attending CBC in the fall of 2006. They became members of the church later that year and faithfully attended and served all three years of seminary. Their daughter, Anna, was born in February 2009. Andy graduated from seminary in May 2009 with his Masters of Divinity. Christy also graduated with her Masters in Church History. After graduation, Andy worked at several different jobs before he was hired at CBC in May of 2011 as the Associate Pastor of Equipping and Discipleship.  Their daughters Ava and Lucy were born in January 2012 and March 2015.  Andy and Christy are glad to be back in the Boston area and are excited to be serving once again at CBC.


General Staff